Good Cover Songs...Isn't That Oxymoronic?
I hate cover songs. Hate 'em. Musicians taking other people's music and ruining it. In my opinion it's lazy. It's okay to like a song. It's okay to play a song you like live at a concert for your fans. Don't record it on an album.
It says to me "Well, I don't have enough creativity to come up with one last track for my CD, so I'll just piggyback off someone else's work." Especially "Knockin' on Heaven's Door." How many times has that been covered? Enough already.
Like all things in life, I thought that there must be some exceptions to the rule. There must be some cover songs that even I like. I tried to think of at least one. I came up with ten. There might be more, but let's face it. There aren't that many good covers, especially ones made after 1999.
Here's my list (in no order) and a little explanation why for each:
1. "Hungry Like the Wolf"- originally by Duran Duran, performed by Reel Big Fish- The reason why is pretty simple. It's different. Reel Big Fish are masters at taking poppy tunes of the '80's and making sweet ska covers out of them. I like it because it sounds little to nothing like the original song other than the lyrics and singing. While okay, I found the original hard to dance to (for me at least), while this cover makes it easy to bust a crazy move or two.
2. "Higher Ground"- originally by Stevie Wonder, performed by Red Hot Chili Peppers- The original was jazzy and fast while the cover was jazzy and fast...and had a sweet bass sound. The melody was the same, but exchange of guitar and bass didn't try to replace or usurp the original, but seemed to add to it. It's like taking an already delicious sandwich, then adding bacon to it.
3. "Turn the Page"- originally by Bob Seger, performed by Metallica- Seger's song about struggle is grand with the sax playing in the background. It's good and mellow and full of uncertainty. Metallica maintained the same feelings and then added the feeling of frustration and quelling anger to the song with heavy guitar riffs substituting the sax and James Hetfield's more aggressive vocals.
4. "Cum on Feel the Noize"- originally by Slade, performed by Quiet Riot- Has anyone in my generation heard of the original version? Didn't think so. Hence the reason it's on the list.
5. "All Along the Watchtower"- originally by Bob Dylan, performed by Jimi Hendrix- I guarantee that many people think that this song was originally performed by Hendrix other than Dylan. Jimi's trademark guitar style adds to a normally slower song.
6. "We're Not Gonna Take It"- originally by Twisted Sister, performed by Bif Naked- A great cover of a metal classic and the only thing Bif Naked is known for.
7. "It's Not Easy Being Green"-originally by Kermit the Frog (Jim Henson), performed by Ray Charles- I love Muppets. I firmly believe that all educational programming, including college material, should be taught by puppets. I also love this song. It speaks on how being yourself and being different is something to celebrate about. It talks about liking who you are instead of striving to be someone else. Ray Charles' vocals have confidence and adds validity to the song's message without the goofiness of Kermit's voice.
8. "Another Brick in the Wall Pt. 1, 2, 3"- originally by Pink Floyd, performed by Korn- I normally cringe whenever anyone covers the immortal Pink Floyd. However, this medley puts all the separated parts together in one long great tribute. Jonathan Davis' voice adds even more passion and anger to an already angry song without tainting the melody.
9. "Pardon Me"- originally by Allison Moorer, performed by Incubus- I was shocked when I found out that this was a cover. Did you know it was a cover? If it's a good enough cover that no one even talks about it being a cover then it's gotta be a great cover. It's also one of my favorite all around tunes.
10. "Hurt"- originally by Nine Inch Nails, performed by Johnny Cash- I hate country. Hate it. Can't stand a second of it. When I flip through the radio and catch a glimpse of a country song, I immediately think "ugh." It's just my taste. This song, however, is my favorite cover. Heck, it's one of my favorite all around songs. The original is pretty good, but the way Cash plays it, it puts a different perspective on the song overall. This is the last single Cash had before he passed away and when you listen to it, it sounds like he is saying his final words and thoughts to the world before he's given his last rites. The pain in the bellow of Cash is resonant and puts more meaning into a song filled of memory and regret. I actually have tears in my eyes whenever I hear it. "I will make you hurt."
Let me know your thoughts. I'd love to hear your opinion of your favorite covers. I still hate them, but like most things in life, there are indeed exceptions. Perhaps, I'll be more receptive to them...as long as it's not "Knockin' On Heaven's Door."
It says to me "Well, I don't have enough creativity to come up with one last track for my CD, so I'll just piggyback off someone else's work." Especially "Knockin' on Heaven's Door." How many times has that been covered? Enough already.
Like all things in life, I thought that there must be some exceptions to the rule. There must be some cover songs that even I like. I tried to think of at least one. I came up with ten. There might be more, but let's face it. There aren't that many good covers, especially ones made after 1999.
Here's my list (in no order) and a little explanation why for each:
1. "Hungry Like the Wolf"- originally by Duran Duran, performed by Reel Big Fish- The reason why is pretty simple. It's different. Reel Big Fish are masters at taking poppy tunes of the '80's and making sweet ska covers out of them. I like it because it sounds little to nothing like the original song other than the lyrics and singing. While okay, I found the original hard to dance to (for me at least), while this cover makes it easy to bust a crazy move or two.
2. "Higher Ground"- originally by Stevie Wonder, performed by Red Hot Chili Peppers- The original was jazzy and fast while the cover was jazzy and fast...and had a sweet bass sound. The melody was the same, but exchange of guitar and bass didn't try to replace or usurp the original, but seemed to add to it. It's like taking an already delicious sandwich, then adding bacon to it.
3. "Turn the Page"- originally by Bob Seger, performed by Metallica- Seger's song about struggle is grand with the sax playing in the background. It's good and mellow and full of uncertainty. Metallica maintained the same feelings and then added the feeling of frustration and quelling anger to the song with heavy guitar riffs substituting the sax and James Hetfield's more aggressive vocals.
4. "Cum on Feel the Noize"- originally by Slade, performed by Quiet Riot- Has anyone in my generation heard of the original version? Didn't think so. Hence the reason it's on the list.
5. "All Along the Watchtower"- originally by Bob Dylan, performed by Jimi Hendrix- I guarantee that many people think that this song was originally performed by Hendrix other than Dylan. Jimi's trademark guitar style adds to a normally slower song.
6. "We're Not Gonna Take It"- originally by Twisted Sister, performed by Bif Naked- A great cover of a metal classic and the only thing Bif Naked is known for.
7. "It's Not Easy Being Green"-originally by Kermit the Frog (Jim Henson), performed by Ray Charles- I love Muppets. I firmly believe that all educational programming, including college material, should be taught by puppets. I also love this song. It speaks on how being yourself and being different is something to celebrate about. It talks about liking who you are instead of striving to be someone else. Ray Charles' vocals have confidence and adds validity to the song's message without the goofiness of Kermit's voice.
8. "Another Brick in the Wall Pt. 1, 2, 3"- originally by Pink Floyd, performed by Korn- I normally cringe whenever anyone covers the immortal Pink Floyd. However, this medley puts all the separated parts together in one long great tribute. Jonathan Davis' voice adds even more passion and anger to an already angry song without tainting the melody.
9. "Pardon Me"- originally by Allison Moorer, performed by Incubus- I was shocked when I found out that this was a cover. Did you know it was a cover? If it's a good enough cover that no one even talks about it being a cover then it's gotta be a great cover. It's also one of my favorite all around tunes.
10. "Hurt"- originally by Nine Inch Nails, performed by Johnny Cash- I hate country. Hate it. Can't stand a second of it. When I flip through the radio and catch a glimpse of a country song, I immediately think "ugh." It's just my taste. This song, however, is my favorite cover. Heck, it's one of my favorite all around songs. The original is pretty good, but the way Cash plays it, it puts a different perspective on the song overall. This is the last single Cash had before he passed away and when you listen to it, it sounds like he is saying his final words and thoughts to the world before he's given his last rites. The pain in the bellow of Cash is resonant and puts more meaning into a song filled of memory and regret. I actually have tears in my eyes whenever I hear it. "I will make you hurt."
Let me know your thoughts. I'd love to hear your opinion of your favorite covers. I still hate them, but like most things in life, there are indeed exceptions. Perhaps, I'll be more receptive to them...as long as it's not "Knockin' On Heaven's Door."
